Port Jefferson Ice Cream Cafe in Port Jefferson

Outstanding soft serve vanilla ice cream

Hands down best ice cream in Port Jefferson. The ice taste great, the amount of ice cream you get is great,and the price is unbeatable.

The best PJ's ice cream ever!

Fantastic!

Visited Port Jeff today and my friend brought me to this ice cream shop. The prices are reasonable, they have loads of flavors and friendly staff. But the greatest of all my vanilla coconut waffle cone ice cream was very delicious, satisfying and so filling. I will be returning to this spot👌🏼

We went to visit port Jefferson and we stop to eat ice cream here was the best decision OMG the ice cream was amazing is huge and I order the cotton candy flavor and is so so good I can even describe how good is this flavor love it love it totally recommend

Good ice cream, good service. Good value! The line can be long, but it generally moves quickly.

Love the ice cream here! The scoops are big and much cheaper than chains. If the weather is nice, you can sit or stroll with you delicious treat.

Ice cream was excellent, alot of choices and great prices

Best ice cream in L.I. Generous portions, delicious flavors and great service!

This is the best ice cream shop you will ever find on Long Island. The young ladies are extremely nice and the ice cream is tops. If they have a line like many times in the Summer they do, it's always worth the extra minutes on line.

Great ice cream and Italian ice shop and very low prices. You won't be disappointed! They have tons of flavors so they have something for everyone.

Best Ice Cream in Port Jeff !

Great ice cream, Great price.

Great ice cream. Great prices. Kind people. Long lines, but worth it. Catch your breath and have a nice conversation with the other people around you on line and forget you're OK busy busy Long Island.

A-Maz-Ing !!

Lines are often long, but the location is great with a nice courtyard and the occasional karaoke going on. Nice harbor views from the north side as well.

One of the best ice cream places in the area

big scoops for less money than i would have expected

Excellent, creamy, beautifully-flavored homemade ice cream. 🍨

Cheap and delicious. Worth going to Port Jefferson for this.

spicy

Great spot for icecream and ices . Hands down the best around town and very reasonable . You won't break the bank...

Great ice cream and great service! Come in the evening on Wednesday nights during the summer for life music with your ice cream.

Amazing, so many flavors and options. Plus it's just an awesome spot

Best ice cream spot in Port Jefferson! Big scoops for a fair price. Don't let the long line fool you, it goes quickly. Grab some napkins and enjoy your favorite flavor combinations! 🍦🍧🍨

Always awesome and no line last night which was like a cherry on top

(1) Good ice cream. (2) Good options to choose from. (3) Good prices. (4) Friendly and warm staff. (5) Perfect location for the after-dinner-ice-cream-stroll.The easiest 5-star review I have written.

Best ice cream shop in the area.